Dating After Divorce for Men Over 40: Hard Lessons Learned

I Want to Feel Like Your Best Choice, Not Your Only Option

“Billy, I like you, but I want to feel like I am your best choice, not your only option.”

Christi said that to me across a two-top in a coffee shop six months after my divorce was final. Fourth date. I had just asked her to be exclusive.

I thought I was being a man about it. Direct. Serious. No games, no keeping her on the hook. Ten years of marriage had taught me exactly one move with a woman I liked, and that move was lock it in.

She was handing me the truth, and I heard a shit test.

So I did what a man who has misread the room always does. I doubled down. Told her I was not interested in anyone else, that I knew what I wanted, that she had nothing to worry about. Every word of that felt like strength on the way out of my mouth.

She was gone within a couple of weeks.

What she actually heard

Here is what I thought I was saying. I really like you.

Here is what landed. Please validate me. Please make me feel normal again. Please do not send me back to my house to be alone.

Women pick that up long before a man says it out loud. It was in the speed. Four dates, and I was ready to shut the whole operation down, not because I knew her, but because being alone was louder than she was.

There is a reason that reads as a warning instead of a compliment. A man who moves that fast is telling you something about his alternatives. If she is the only door, then she was never a choice he made; she is a door he found. Being wanted is flattering. Being needed is a job.

I would have argued with every word of that at the time. I would have told you I was an honest guy who knew his own mind. What I actually was was a man who had not spent a lot of time alone since the papers were signed, using a beautiful woman in a coffee shop as a painkiller.

Why Divorced Men Run That Play

Ten years (relationship for three years, married for 7). That is how long I had been somebody’s husband. It was the only software I had.

And the game had changed while I was inside. Before I got married, dating was simple. You saw somebody who caught your eye, you walked over, you talked, and you got a number. Getting a number was an event back then. Then you called her on a phone, and you actually talked, and then you asked her out. If she was single and you were not a disaster, it usually turned into something, because neither of you was sitting on a stack of maybes.

I came out in 2008, and there was Match and Plenty of Fish and a dozen others behind them. Everybody suddenly had the illusion of a hundred options, and nobody had to get to know anybody. I was running dial-up in a broadband world, and I had no idea. I still thought the play was to find one good one and secure her, because that is what the last decade of my life had rewarded.

Most divorced men are not needy by nature. We are running the last relationship’s operating system on a machine that got replaced while we were gone.

Then I did it again

You would think Christi cured me. She did not.

The next woman I dated was nowhere near as kind, and she clocked my need for validation the way a mechanic hears a bad bearing. She kept me on maybe. Maybe later. Maybe once things settle down. Maybe let us just see where this goes.

Meanwhile, she had my attention, my time, and my company, with her options wide open. She was also still entertaining an ex.

And I stayed for it. Read that again. A grown man stayed for maybe, because maybe he was quieter than the quiet.

That is when it finally landed.

Attention is not commitment. Chemistry is not character. Access is not the same thing as reciprocity.

She let me into the building. She never gave me a key. I kept calling it patience when the honest word was convenient.

The shift that fixed it

What changed everything was not a technique.

I stopped walking into dates asking whether she liked me and started walking in asking whether I liked her. To be honest, I wanted to see if she could hold my interest while I did a vibe check on her presence.

It sounds small. It rebuilt the entire thing.

With Christi and the one after her, I was auditioning. Best behavior, best stories, agreeing with things I did not agree with, quietly applying for the position of boyfriend, and hoping the hiring manager saw potential. I was trying to fit myself into her life.

After that I started asking a different set of questions on the drive home. Am I actually attracted to this woman, or am I attracted to being wanted? Do I like her, or do I like not being by myself on a Thursday? How does she treat the waiter, her mother, and the guy who cut her off in the parking lot? What is her energy like when nothing is going her way?

Looks fade. I have watched it happen to gorgeous people. How somebody treats a person who can do nothing for them does not fade, and that is the thing you are actually going to be sitting across from at sixty-two.

Two rules came out of that season, and I have never put them down.

It is just dating until it becomes something more. Four dates is four dates. It is not a relationship, it is not a betrayal if she is seeing other people, and it is not a referendum on your worth as a man.

Nobody owes anybody anything yet. She does not owe you exclusivity. You do not owe her the edited version of yourself you think she wants. You are two people finding out whether this works.

Once I actually believed those two things, dating got easy. I did not get better at women. I stopped taking it so damn seriously and started having fun with it.

What that looks like on an actual date

Slow the exclusivity clock all the way down. You do not know a woman at four dates. You know her representative. Wait until you have seen her handle something going wrong or seen her get told no before you start deciding what she is going to be to you. If she is worth locking in, she will still be worth locking in a month later.

Stop rearranging your life around a maybe. Keep the training session. Keep the poker night. Keep dinner with your kid. A man who cancels his own life for a third date has told her the whole story about how much life he has. And pay attention to what happens when you do not cancel, because that reaction is free information and it comes early.

Ask the drive-home question every single time. Do I actually want to see her again, or do I want to be wanted again? Those two things feel almost identical in the moment, and they lead to completely different years.

And stop reading silence as a verdict on you. She did not text back. That is a data point about her interest, her week, or her ex. It is not a grade on your worth or your manhood. The man who can sit with an unanswered text without flinching is the same man who does not need to ask for exclusivity on date four.

What Nobody Tells You About Dating After Divorce

Here is what sits underneath all of it, and it is why most of the advice out there does not work.

You cannot fake this. It has to be in you, not on you.

You can read the line about being her best choice and try to perform it. Text slower on purpose. Hold something back on purpose. Act like you have options you do not have. She will smell it inside of a week, because a performance of abundance is just neediness in a bad suit, and the bad suit never fits right.

The only way to stop being desperate for a woman’s approval is to build a life you would genuinely pick over her approval. Not a life that looks good written down. An actual Tuesday you like living. Work that means something to you, a body you take care of, money that is not a low-grade panic in the back of your skull, two or three men who would tell you the truth to your face, and something you are building that does not depend on anybody’s opinion of you.

I want to be careful here, because this is exactly where the internet lies to men. It will tell you to get abs and get money, and the rest sorts itself out. I have run that experiment personally, in both directions. I was sixty pounds overweight and doing fine. I was in the best shape of my life, unemployed, and doing better than fine. Neither one was the variable.

The variable was whether my own life was absorbing enough that I was not auditioning for a spot in somebody else’s.

That is not a decision you make. It is a thing you build. And you have to build it whether or not a woman ever shows up to appreciate it, which is precisely why it works when she does.

Christi was right (Thank you, Christi), and it took me two more women and about two years to hear it properly.

I want to feel like I am your best choice, not your only option.

Be a man with options. Not a phone full of them. A life full of them.

That is chapter seven of The Comeback Code, and it works because of the six chapters sitting in front of it.

The book is $37 and it is the whole system. Body, mind, purpose, money, relationships, and brotherhood. In that order, on purpose, because dating is the part that gets easier once the rest of your life stops being an emergency. Thirty-day money back, no forms, no hoops.

GET THE COMEBACK CODE  →  $37